HOW COULD SATAN FALL IF HE IS IN HEAVEN?
The Bible gives us very limited details about the origin of Satan. Even the passages often cited about his fall—such as Isaiah 14 and Ezekiel 28—remain debated to this day. Even in Genesis 3, where the serpent is introduced in Eden, the writer did not explain who the serpent really was or why it appeared in the garden. The idea that Satan was indeed the serpent comes largely from later Christian tradition, though it is supported by biblical passages such as Revelation 12:9.
But how exactly did Satan sin if he was in the presence of a holy God? The truth is, we are only speculating, since Scripture does not provide a direct explanation. While this question remains unanswered, there are biblical truths worth reflecting on that may lead us toward a possible answer. Scholars have proposed various valid views, while others, such as Reformed theologian John Piper, admit that it is ultimately a mystery. Piper (2013) writes: “How did Satan become evil? I do not know… To say that Satan had free will—that is, ultimate self-determination—is not an explanation for why he committed his first sin. It is a label. It is not an explanation.” He has a point, since we really do not know exactly how Satan rebelled against God. We can only assume that it happened.
Did the Desire to Sin Come From God?
Some extreme Calvinists suggest that the Devil simply followed a desire given to him by God, which supposedly led to his rebellion. But this theory makes God the cause of Satan’s sin—a view that directly contradicts God’s holiness. Theologian Norman Geisler argues: “Opposites cannot both be true at the same time and in the same sense. God cannot be good and not good. He cannot be for His own essential good and be against it by giving Lucifer the desire to sin against Him. In short, God cannot be for Himself and against Himself at the same time and in the same sense.” The Bible’s strong emphasis on God’s holiness is more than enough reason to reject such an idea.
Freedom to Choose
A common explanation is that Satan, like other spiritual beings and humans, was created with the ability to choose. Because God is love and holiness, He desired that His creatures love Him freely and reflect His holiness. As Arthur B. Fowler puts it: “By logical necessity love and holiness cannot be forced. Compulsory love or holiness could not satisfy the all-wise Creator. Therefore these loving and holy creatures must be able to choose whether to glorify God and to enjoy Him forever or to reject Him or suffer the consequences.” God’s own nature and desire for His creation required that they be given freedom to choose.
Distance and Cloaking
Some scholars suggest that because spiritual beings like Satan were created with freedom, God also “distanced” Himself from them to give them genuine space to choose. In other words, He did not make His presence “overwhelmingly obvious.” Just as He gave Adam and Eve the ability to choose—and allowed both the forbidden tree and the serpent in Eden—He gave spiritual beings the opportunity to decide. Theologian Guy M. Richard (2022) explains: “Angels, therefore, had the opportunity to choose God or choose not-God, that anti-God posture. And that anti-God posture is what we’re saying evil is.” And we know what happened—Satan chose to be anti-God.
Christian philosopher William Lane Craig (2017) calls this “epistemic distance”: “God has created us at an ‘epistemic distance,’ so to speak, which allows us the freedom to rebel against Him and separate ourselves from Him. This world is a vale of decision-making during which we decide whether we want to live with God forever or reject Him and so irrevocably separate ourselves from Him… Something like this may have already occurred with angelic beings. Originally created ‘at arm’s length’ from God epistemically, they had a time to choose either for or against God.”
Interestingly, Piper (2013) observes something similar, calling it the “cloaking of glory.” He suggests that God did not fully reveal His glory to spiritual beings like Lucifer: “I am not saying this is a foolproof explanation of sin, but somehow God cloaked his glory from Lucifer, and in the cloaking of his glory—somehow still inexplicable to me—there rises a preference in Lucifer’s heart for himself over God, who has cloaked his glory.” Whether we describe it as distance or cloaking, the point is that God allowed His creatures the genuine opportunity to choose.
______
This is certainly an intriguing topic, and there is nothing wrong with believers asking such questions. God assures us that even if we do not find complete answers in this life, eternity will reveal them all: “For nothing is hidden that will not be made manifest, nor is anything secret that will not be known and come to light.” (Luke 8:17). Stay Curious.
Sources and Studies:
Piper, J. (2013, October 14). Where did Satan’s first desire for evil come from? Desiring God. Retrieved from https://www.desiringgod.org/interviews/where-did-satans-first-desire-for-evil-come-from
Comments
Post a Comment